Logic pro x pitch correction vs melodyne free. The best plug-ins for Auto-Tune effects and pitch correction

Looking for:

Melodyne vs Flex Pitch (Which Is Best?) | Whipped Cream Sounds - MAutoPitch | MeldaProduction 

Click here to DOWNLOAD

     

ANTARES AUTOTUNE vs. MELODYNE - Music Production Techniques and Gear - Logic Pro Help - Similar Threads

 

Log in Register. Search titles only. Search Advanced search…. Forums Latest Posts Search forums. What's new. Alerts Loading…. Show all… Preferences. Everywhere Threads This forum This thread. Filters Search. Latest Posts. Search forums. JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.

You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly. You should upgrade or use an alternative browser. I compared 4 pitch correction plugins. Here are the results! Thread starter Logic pro x pitch correction vs melodyne free Start date Jul 11, QuiteAlright Gastronomer. Hello all! I was wondering how similar current pitch correction plugins are to each other, and which ones have the highest /23227.txt. So I tested several of them lovic, and I want to share the results for anyone else who's interested here.

I posted this first on KVR and Reddit, but wanted to share here as well. Logic pro x pitch correction vs melodyne free in order to test them in a way that would expose some weaknesses, I put them through vree stress test. I picked a vocal sample which was already in tune, from an Alicia Keys song, and pittch it 5 semitones up.

This is a major enough change that we can easily hear artifacts and compare the results, so it makes it very interesting to compare them. However, I'll acknowledge that this isn't a typical use case for these, so it's possible that this is a bit посетить страницу towards plugins that are optimized for subtle changes. I'll add my own thoughts, as well as some clarification, below. I think some of the dynamics have been lost correctlon, and while it does sound the most human, I think it also degrades the quality of the recording a lot.

In terms of usage outside of this benchmark, I found that the interface does a great job of grouping notes together in the way I would expect as a producer, meaning that there weren't any tiny sub-notes disconnected from vree main singing. Melodyne does some sibilance detection and handles sibilant sounds differently when correcting the pitch, which I think helps make it sound more natural.

I think those two aspects of it are very valuable, and make it stand out. It also offers a volume levelling feature to make quiet notes louder and vice versa, which none of the others have. However, in practice, I got terrible results with that feature. Melodyne lacks any sort of synthetic vibrato, which I feel is a shame for a plugin that costs this much. Even though many would say that synthetic vibrato is a gimmick, Waves and CrispyTuner both give you that feature at far lower prices.

Waves Tune produces a very sharp sounding result with very crisp tones, but it has a huge artifact towards the end of the sample. It's worth keeping in mind that all of these plugins received the exact same input, but this was the only one that had such a huge issue. Outside of the benchmark, I have a few other complaints here. The interface is straight out of the '90s, and it just looks like a dinosaur of a plugin compared to the others. The note detection struggles and often splits up a note into 3 notes, with one tiny little out of tune one in the middle.

With those complaints out of the way though, /17484.txt really packed with features. It can handle natural vibrato, synthetic vibrato, and even allows you to draw the pitch directly into any shape you want no other tested coreection allows this.

That allows a lot of creativity in my opinion. One piitch feature of Waves that I love is that the piano logic pro x pitch correction vs melodyne free can play fs reference note for you for instance, playing a reference C3 note. This helps a вот ссылка when you're moving vocals between notes rather than quantizing them. It's almost unfair to include CrispyTuner here because of a quirk compared to the others.

In this plugin, the pitch curve gets mapped to a series of quantized "target notes" during the recording at least in the graphical mode. That means that when you logic pro x pitch correction vs melodyne free the fere, you're transposing the quantized notes instead of the pitches that the singer actually hit.

And when it's time to correct, it simply snaps the pitch correctoon to those target notes, which means that this one has more of an "auto tune" sound versus logic pro x pitch correction vs melodyne free other ones, which are just directly transposing the vocals. I thought about removing this, but I think it's fair to include because it's a direct competitor to the others, and because this seems like a limitation that should be noted.

It's worth noting that CrispyTuner is a new mlodyne, so this could easily be fixed in the future. And of the plugins here, this one is actually under active development along with Melodyne but that one's pace is far slowerwhich makes me think that it might rpo surpass a lot of the others. The interface is good and it has the advantage of being capable of live tuning as well, which is unique among these.

I pifch the "slide" feature of this one, which lets you slide from one note to another smoothly, and the fact that it includes nice extras like synthetic vibrato. And I llgic the note detection could be massively improved. This plugin does let you customize meloeyne note detection parameters, but it seems to detect notes only through forwards playback like Waves kelodyne than analyzing the whole piece like Melodyne and NewTone.

The result is that there are a lot of tiny mistaken notes. As a very minor thing, it would also be great lpgic copy the ability to "draw" a pitch like Waves does, but that's much less important than the aforementioned issues.

So again, I think there's a lot of potential here, but also a нажмите для деталей room for improvement. I wouldn't use this personally until some of the above is fixed. NewTone keeps the sharpness of the original, but has продолжить more robotic fdee to it than others.

There are a few places where you can hear the tuning come in a bit heavy correctipn, and I think the clarity isn't worth it in this case. It's worth noting that Logic pro x pitch correction vs melodyne free is especially buggy. It crashed twice during logic pro x pitch correction vs melodyne free testing, and several times it turned prro clip into a guttural growling noise. It took me several attempts to get this to produce a proper result.

The note detection is quite good as well. Feee results are what I would consider the second best, after Melodyne. However, it was so unstable that I would never depend on it for professional corection. But personally, I feel that Melodyne performed best in this benchmark.

If anyone else wants to add their own experiences, or try this out in the plugins that I didn't try myself, please leave your opinion as well. Click to read more Artemi Active Member.

I really appreciate this logic pro x pitch correction vs melodyne free, as far as I remember with my own tests you can get good results with melodyne if you know how to work with it, it has a specific workflow. I use melodyne sometimes and get good results and have autotune as well for a few occasions Although a lot of the the time I still use my Daw's pitch correction melodyje DP10 which is quick and fast and has logic pro x pitch correction vs melodyne free good algorhythms without artifacts.

I use to take vocal phrases and make them original phrases using Meldoyne and Cubase a lot. No interest in any other type of pitch pri. Imo, Melodyne produced the most natural output in your benchmark. I think the muffling is inevitable because of the way Melodyne works and the range of your pitch-shifting. But you should be able to reverse this, add energy back into the vocals using either a post-EQ or an exciter. SteveC Active Member. Which version of Melodyne did you use? Maybe the formant llogic could help!

Maarten Member. Thanks for your tests! And it confirmed my 10 game mode free also, Melodyne is the most natural. QuiteAlright Gastronomer Thread starter. SteveC said:. Click emlodyne expand Above mentioned software works well, and for hardware the 2 options I like to use are excellent for real time live work where vocals or even interesting artifacts on instruments can be used. I actually prefer using PC on drifting vocalists that get tired after the first of two 90 version microsoft free product 2016 full key with free powerpoint sets.

Zero artifacts on either of these units, but using combinations of both in an automated chain of по этому сообщению gets the job done. Especially when pfo LoFi quality needs to be kicked frer for 4 bars, etc. AudioLoco Senior Member. Pity you didn't include the main benchmark Antares AutoTune AudioLoco said:. VSriHarsha Senior Member. You melodnye log in or register to reply here.